Home / Home & Garden / One Good Chef’s Knife or a Block Set? Kitchen Knives Compared

One Good Chef’s Knife or a Block Set? Kitchen Knives Compared

Kitchen knives in a UK kitchen: chef's knife on a wooden chopping board with onions and thyme, knife block and magnetic strip behind

Most kitchen drawers have a tangle of knives and one that actually gets used. If you’re buying kitchen knives for yourself or as a Christmas present for a keen cook, the first decision is whether to spend on one good chef’s knife or on a knife block set. A 20cm chef’s knife does most of the work in a home kitchen, and a set adds a bread knife, a paring knife and a few you might never touch. This guide covers both, from £17 starter blocks to £126 forged German knives, plus Japanese-style blades and how to keep them sharp.

We checked ten products on Amazon UK on 30 October for a London postcode, from £16.79 to £199.99. Six are sold by Amazon; the other four come from third-party sellers, flagged on each one. Two of the knives were picks in The Guardian’s chef’s knife test, published on 20 March 2026, where chef Ben Lippett tried 14 knives. Comments on sharpness and how well an edge lasts are his findings from that test. We haven’t tested these knives ourselves, and Which? scores sit behind its members’ paywall, so we don’t quote them.

Why now? Black Friday is on 27 November, and a good knife is one of the easier foodie gifts to get right. If you’re kitting out a kitchen, pair your new knife with our non-stick frying pan guide, and if you chop onions by the kilo for batch cooking, a food processor will do that faster than any blade.

How to choose kitchen knives

One good chef’s knife or a block set?

For most people, one good chef’s knife plus a cheap bread knife and paring knife beats a big block. The Guardian’s reviewer makes much the same point: a do-it-all chef’s knife, a small paring knife and a serrated bread knife “will complete almost any task”. A set makes sense when you’re starting from nothing, want a matching look on the worktop or want a built-in sharpener. Count the pieces you would actually use before paying for the rest.

The set discount trap

Knife sets on Amazon often show a struck-through reference price, and big piece counts are padded with steak knives, scissors and the block itself. Work out the price per knife you’d use. Take the six steak knives, the scissors, the steel and the block out of the 14-piece Amazon Basics set and you have five kitchen knives. Look at the price history before Black Friday too: several knives here were already a few pounds below their reference prices in late October, and the Wüsthof was slightly dearer than when the Guardian tested it.

Western or Japanese-style?

Western (German-style) chef’s knives such as the Wüsthof and Robert Welch have a curved blade for a rocking chop, a heavier build and a slightly wider edge angle. Japanese-style knives such as the Global G-2 and the santoku shape are usually lighter and flatter, with a narrower edge for push-cutting and slicing. The Guardian’s reviewer suggests starting here: if the tip of your knife never leaves the board, go western. If you chop straight down, a Japanese-style blade may suit you better.

Handle fit and blade length

A sharp knife that’s uncomfortable to hold will stay in the drawer. Try to hold a few in a shop such as John Lewis or a local cookshop before buying online. A 20cm blade is the usual all-rounder; go smaller (14cm to 17cm) for small hands or a tiny chopping board. Check the handle material too: plastic and POM handles are tough and grippy, wood looks nicer but needs the odd wipe of food-safe oil.

Care: no dishwasher, and block or magnetic strip?

Some listings, including the Victorinox Fibrox, say dishwasher safe. The knife care advice in the Guardian piece, from Helen Symonds of Kitchen Provisions, says “no dishwasher. Ever. Not even quickly”, because the water blunts the blade and the heat weakens handle glue. Wash by hand, tip down, and dry straight away. Cut on wood or plastic boards, never glass or stone. If you carve a turkey in one of our roasting tins, use the slicing knife and a board, not the tin.

Symonds prefers a magnetic strip, ideally with a wood or cork face, to a block, because blades can rub on the slot going in and out and blocks collect crumbs. A strip such as the Coninx 40cm magnetic knife rack (£18.99 from a third-party seller, 6,629 ratings) frees up worktop space. Mount it out of children’s reach. Pull-through sharpeners are quick but less even than a whetstone; whichever you use, follow the maker’s instructions and keep fingers clear of the edge.

Buying knives as a gift: the age rule

Kitchen knives are a present for adults. GOV.UK says it is illegal to “sell most knives or any weapons to anyone under the age of 18”, and adds: “In Scotland, you’re allowed to sell 16 and 17 year olds cutlery and kitchen knives.”

The Guardian’s Best Overall, Still Near Its Test Price: WÜSTHOF Classic 20cm Chef’s Knife

Premium · 20cm (8 inch) blade · forged from one block of high-carbon stainless steel · 58 HRC (Wüsthof) · full tang, triple-riveted handle, full bolster · hand wash only · model 1040100120 · reference price £145.00 · £126.15

The Wüsthof Classic 20cm was £126.15, sold and dispatched by Amazon, with 2,839 ratings and a struck-through reference price of £145.00. Checked on 30 October for a London postcode.

This is the knife The Guardian’s chef’s knife test named best overall after chef Ben Lippett tried 14 knives over a fortnight. At the time of the test it was listed at £121.18 at Amazon, so today’s price is a few pounds above that. The reviewer gave it five stars and wrote that it has “a mean edge” and a “balanced heft”. Those are his findings; we haven’t run our own test.

Wüsthof says the blade is forged from a single block of steel and hardened to 58 HRC, with a full tang and three rivets through the handle. The curved German-style blade suits the rocking chop most British home cooks already use, where the tip stays on the board. The full bolster at the heel adds weight and protects your fingers, though it also means you can’t sharpen the last centimetre of edge as easily.

Wüsthof says hand wash only. It’s the knife to buy if you want one really good blade and plan to keep it for years.

✅ Guardian’s best overall pick
✅ Sold by Amazon
✅ Balanced, forged German blade
❌ Over £120
❌ Bolster makes heel harder to sharpen
❌ Price is above the Guardian’s test price

👉 Check Price on Amazon UK

The All-Steel Japanese Classic: Global G-2 20cm Cook’s Knife

Premium · 20cm blade · Cromova 18 stainless steel · convex 15° edge (Global) · one-piece steel with hollow, sand-weighted handle · 222g · made in Japan · hand wash only · model G-2 · £124.95

The Global G-2 was £124.95, sold by IGL Commerce Ltd and dispatched by Amazon, with 2,863 ratings. The listing names I Grunwerg, Global’s long-standing UK distributor, as the manufacturer contact. Checked on 30 October for a London postcode.

The G-2 has been the go-to Japanese-style knife in British kitchens for decades. Global says it has a convex 15° edge, which is a narrower angle than a typical German knife and feels very keen out of the box. At 222g it is light, with a one-piece steel body and a hollow handle filled with sand to balance the blade.

The shape is flatter and the blade thinner than the Wüsthof. That suits push-cutting and slicing and is less happy with the heavy rocking chop. The steel handle with its dimpled grip divides people: some love it, others find it slippery with wet hands. Try one in a shop if you can.

Thin edges need more care. Don’t use it on frozen food or bones, and Global says to hand wash and dry it straight away.

✅ Light and very keen edge
✅ One-piece steel, no seams
✅ Made in Japan
❌ Steel handle not for everyone
❌ Thin edge needs care
❌ Third-party seller

👉 Check Price on Amazon UK

The Block Set That Sharpens Itself: Ninja Foodi StaySharp 6-Piece Knife Block Set

Premium · 20cm chef, 20cm bread, 20cm slicing, 13cm utility, 9cm paring knife + scissors · block with integrated sharpener · forged German stainless steel, double-rivet handles · 2.46kg total · block H32.1 x W18.9 x D36.5cm · 10-year replacement guarantee on registration (Ninja) · £199.99

The Ninja Foodi StaySharp 6-piece set was £199.99, sold and dispatched by Amazon, with 5,569 ratings. Amazon ranked it number one in Kitchen Knife Sets on the day. Checked on 30 October for a London postcode.

The selling point is the sharpener built into the block. You pull a knife through the slot now and then and keep the edge going without learning to use a whetstone. You get a 20cm chef’s knife, a bread knife, a slicing knife for the Sunday roast, a utility knife, a paring knife and scissors.

Ninja offers a 10-year replacement guarantee if you register the set and follow its care guide. The block is big, at about 32cm high and 36.5cm deep, so measure under your wall cupboards first, especially in a narrow galley kitchen.

£200 is a lot for knives you may not all use. If you’d only reach for the chef’s knife and the bread knife, buying those two separately costs less. Pull-through sharpeners are also quick but less precise than a stone, which is a fair trade for most home cooks.

✅ Sharpener in the block
✅ Sold by Amazon, huge rating count
✅ 10-year guarantee on registration
❌ Big block for small kitchens
❌ £200 for six pieces
❌ Pull-through sharpening is less precise

👉 Check Price on Amazon UK

The British-Designed Rocker Under £70: Robert Welch Signature 20cm Cook’s Knife

Best Value · 20cm curved blade · German 1.4116 stainless steel, Rockwell 56 (Robert Welch) · hand-applied 15° edge · fully forged, full tang, angled bolster · POM handle moulded onto the tang · lifetime guarantee against manufacturing defects (Robert Welch) · only 10 left · £68.00

The Robert Welch Signature 20cm was £68.00, sold by Robert Welch‘s own Amazon storefront and dispatched by Amazon, with 424 ratings and only 10 left in stock. Checked on 30 October for a London postcode.

Robert Welch is a Chipping Campden design firm, and the Signature range is its everyday line. The blade is German 1.4116 steel with a hand-applied 15° edge, and the curved profile is built for a rocking chop. The angled bolster lets you use the whole edge, so it is easier to sharpen right to the heel than the Wüsthof.

The Guardian tested the smaller 14cm Signature cook’s knife, not this one. It liked the comfort but found the edge “very coarse” out of the box and said it bit into a wooden board. The longer 20cm blade here handles a whole cabbage or squash better than the 14cm.

Robert Welch quotes CATRA tests for sharpness and gives a lifetime guarantee against manufacturing defects. That covers faults, so normal wear and chips are on you.

✅ Half the price of the Wüsthof
✅ Easy to sharpen to the heel
✅ Maker’s defect guarantee
❌ Guardian found the 14cm edge coarse
❌ Only 10 left when checked
❌ Third-party seller (the brand)

👉 Check Price on Amazon UK

The Slim Block for a Narrow Worktop: Joseph Joseph Elevate SlimBlock 5-Piece Knife Block Set

Best Value · 9cm paring, 11.4cm serrated, 14cm santoku, 16.5cm chef’s, 20cm bread knife · Japanese stainless-steel blades · weighted handles with knife rests · slim block with removable two-stage ceramic sharpener · 1.52kg · reference price £105.00 · £89.25

The Joseph Joseph Elevate SlimBlock was £89.25 against a reference price of £105.00, sold and dispatched by Amazon, with 582 ratings. Checked on 30 October for a London postcode.

The block is only about 7.5cm wide on Amazon’s dimensions, so it fits beside the kettle on a small worktop. A two-stage ceramic sharpener slides out of the base. The handles are weighted, with little rests, so when you put a knife down the blade stays off the worktop.

Check the sizes before you buy it as a main set. The chef’s knife is 16.5cm, shorter than the 20cm the Guardian’s reviewer calls the usual all-rounder size. That’s fine for smaller hands and smaller kitchens, a bit short for a big squash.

The black plastic handles look neat and won’t suit anyone who wants wood and rivets. Joseph Joseph says hand wash only.

✅ Slim block for small kitchens
✅ Sharpener in the base
✅ Sold by Amazon
❌ 16.5cm chef’s knife is on the short side
❌ Plastic handles
❌ Reference price looks generous

👉 Check Price on Amazon UK

Five Swiss Knives Without a Block: Victorinox Swiss Classic 5-Piece Kitchen Knife Set

Best Value · chef’s knife, bread knife, 2 paring knives (wavy and pointed), tomato and table knife · Swiss Classic plastic handles · gift box · item 6.7133.5G · 1-year manufacturer warranty (listing) · reference price £89.00 · £85.03

The Victorinox Swiss Classic 5-piece set was £85.03, sold and dispatched by Amazon, with 1,144 ratings. Checked on 30 October for a London postcode.

This is the answer for anyone who wants a few good knives and already has a magnetic strip or a drawer insert. You get a chef’s knife, a bread knife, two paring knives and a serrated tomato knife in a box, with no block taking up space.

Victorinox handles are plain plastic. The Guardian’s reviewer said of the Fibrox chef’s knife that the handle “could use a bit of a glow-up”, and the Swiss Classic handles are a similar idea. The blades are thin and light, and Victorinox is a name many chefs started on.

The listing doesn’t give blade lengths for every piece, so check the pictures if size matters. The £85.03 is close to the £89.00 reference price, so it isn’t a big discount, and Black Friday may bring it lower.

✅ Sold by Amazon
✅ No bulky block
✅ Bread and chef’s knife included
❌ Plain plastic handles
❌ Blade lengths not all listed
❌ Only a small discount today

👉 Check Price on Amazon UK

The Santoku for Push-Cutters: Victorinox Swiss Classic Santoku Knife 17cm

Best Value · 17cm fluted (hollow-edge) blade · 107g · TPE handle · item 6.8523.17B · £47.00

The Victorinox Swiss Classic Santoku 17cm was £47.00, sold and dispatched by Amazon, with 2,437 ratings at 4.8 stars. Checked on 30 October for a London postcode.

A santoku is the Japanese-style all-rounder: a flatter, taller blade with a rounded nose, made for chopping straight down or pushing forward through veg. If you never rock your knife, a santoku often feels more natural than a curved chef’s knife. This one has a fluted edge, the scallops along the side that help slices of potato or cucumber fall away.

It weighs just 107g, so it is easy on the wrist for long prep sessions. The flip side is that it lacks weight for big jobs like halving a swede.

At under £50 it is a good test of whether you like the Japanese shape before spending £120 or more on something like the Global.

✅ Under £50 from Victorinox
✅ Fluted edge stops sticking
✅ Light and easy to control
❌ Too light for heavy roots
❌ Plastic handle
❌ No tip for fine point work

👉 Check Price on Amazon UK

The Guardian’s Best Budget Chef’s Knife: Victorinox Fibrox 20cm Chef’s Knife

Budget · 20cm extra-broad blade · Fibrox polypropylene handle · 190g (listing) · model 5.2063.20 · reference price £47.50 · £38.99

The Victorinox Fibrox 20cm was £38.99 against a reference price of £47.50, sold by Tyh Group and dispatched by Amazon, with 1,907 ratings. Checked on 30 October for a London postcode.

The Guardian’s chef’s knife test named it best budget knife, listed at £43 from Victorinox at the time of the test. The reviewer said he started his cooking career with it and found it razor sharp and well balanced. He also noted that the edge “doesn’t last as long as more expensive models, but it’s easy to sharpen”.

The extra-broad 20cm blade gives your knuckles plenty of room above the board, and the grippy Fibrox handle is the sort you see in catering kitchens. It’s plain to look at, which is the main reason it costs a third of the Wüsthof.

Amazon’s listing marks it dishwasher safe. The Guardian’s knife care advice from Kitchen Provisions is blunt: “no dishwasher. Ever.” Wash it by hand and it will stay sharper for longer.

✅ Guardian’s best budget pick
✅ Under £40
✅ Easy to sharpen
❌ Edge needs more frequent sharpening
❌ Plain plastic handle
❌ Third-party seller

👉 Check Price on Amazon UK

The Bestselling Block Set Under £50: D.Perlla 7-Piece Knife Set with Self-Sharpening Wooden Block

Budget · 20cm chef, 20cm slicing, 20cm bread, 13cm utility, 9cm paring knife + shears · wooden block with built-in sharpener · forged high-carbon stainless steel, triple-rivet handles (listing) · 2.27kg · reference price £49.99 · £43.99

The D.Perlla 7-piece set was £43.99 against a reference price of £49.99, sold by GringGOT and dispatched by Amazon, with 3,332 ratings. Amazon had it at number three in Kitchen Knife Sets. Checked on 30 October for a London postcode.

For under £50 you get a full block: 20cm chef’s, slicing and bread knives, a utility knife, a paring knife, shears and a wooden block with a sharpener built in. It is the same idea as the Ninja set for about a fifth of the price.

The steel and the build are cheaper, and D.Perlla is a newer online brand with nowhere near the track record of Wüsthof or Victorinox. Listing claims such as “super sharp” are the seller’s own words. If you want a starter set for a first flat or a student kitchen, it covers every job.

D.Perlla recommends hand washing and drying straight away, and its listing says under-18s should only use the knives with adult supervision.

✅ Full block set under £50
✅ Built-in sharpener
✅ Big rating count
❌ Little-known brand
❌ Third-party seller
❌ Cheaper steel than the big names

👉 Check Price on Amazon UK

The £17 Starter Block for a First Flat: Amazon Basics 14-Piece Kitchen Knife Set with Block

Budget · 20.3cm chef, slicing and bread knives, 14cm utility, 9cm paring, 6 steak knives, scissors, sharpening steel · pine block 35.8 x 20.1 x 11cm · triple-rivet full-tang handles (listing) · hand wash only · £16.79

The Amazon Basics 14-piece set was £16.79, sold and dispatched by Amazon, with 21,856 ratings, the most of anything we checked. Checked on 30 October for a London postcode.

Fourteen pieces for under £17 sounds too good, and in a way it is. Six of them are steak knives, and the scissors, a sharpening steel and the pine block count too. What matters is that you also get a 20.3cm chef’s knife, a bread knife and a paring knife, which covers most cooking.

Expect a basic edge that will need attention sooner than the dearer knives here. A sharpening steel comes in the box (Amazon’s product image shows it), so learn to use it little and often.

It’s a sensible buy for a student, a holiday let or a first rented flat. As a Christmas present for a keen cook, it will look cheap next to anything else in this guide.

✅ Under £17, sold by Amazon
✅ Huge rating count
✅ Covers every basic job
❌ Basic steel, dulls sooner
❌ Looks cheap as a gift
❌ Piece count padded by steak knives

👉 Check Price on Amazon UK

Also checked

The Opinel Parallèle N°118, the Guardian’s best knife for beginners, was listed at £33.99 but showed as temporarily out of stock. The Global G-46 santoku was £118.99 with only one left, and the MAC TH-80 was £118.00 from a third-party seller. The Taylors Eye Witness Sabatier Professional 20cm was £19.99 with five left, a cheaper alternative to the Fibrox. We also saw an older listing of the Wüsthof Classic at £116.20 from a third-party seller, and the Joseph Joseph Duo 5-piece set at £39.99 without clear stock.

Quick comparison

ProductTierTypePrice checkedRatingsSold byAmazon
WÜSTHOF Classic 20cm Chef’s KnifePremiumWestern chef’s knife, 20cm£126.152,839AmazonView
Global G-2 20cm Cook’s KnifePremiumJapanese-style chef’s knife, 20cm£124.952,863IGL Commerce Ltd (third party, dispatched by Amazon)View
Ninja Foodi StaySharp 6-Piece Knife Block SetPremiumBlock set with built-in sharpener£199.995,569AmazonView
Robert Welch Signature 20cm Cook’s KnifeBest ValueWestern chef’s knife, 20cm£68.00424Robert Welch (third party, dispatched by Amazon)View
Joseph Joseph Elevate SlimBlock 5-Piece Knife Block SetBest ValueBlock set, Japanese-steel blades£89.25582AmazonView
Victorinox Swiss Classic 5-Piece Kitchen Knife SetBest ValueGift-boxed set, no block£85.031,144AmazonView
Victorinox Swiss Classic Santoku Knife 17cmBest ValueJapanese-style santoku, 17cm£47.002,437AmazonView
Victorinox Fibrox 20cm Chef’s KnifeBudgetWestern chef’s knife, 20cm£38.991,907Tyh Group (third party, dispatched by Amazon)View
D.Perlla 7-Piece Knife Set with Self-Sharpening Wooden BlockBudgetBlock set with built-in sharpener£43.993,332GringGOT (third party, dispatched by Amazon)View
Amazon Basics 14-Piece Kitchen Knife Set with BlockBudget14-piece block set£16.7921,856AmazonView

Prices, sellers, stock and rating counts from Amazon UK listings on 30 October 2026 (London postcode, VAT included). Steel grades, hardness, edge angles and guarantees are as stated by the makers or Amazon listings. Guardian test details and prices are as published on 20 March 2026, at the time of the test.

Gift picks by budget

Under £50: the Victorinox Fibrox 20cm (£38.99) for a cook who wants one proper knife, the Victorinox santoku (£47.00) for someone curious about the Japanese shape, or the D.Perlla block (£43.99) for a first home. Under £120: the Robert Welch Signature 20cm (£68.00), the Victorinox Swiss Classic 5-piece set (£85.03) or the Joseph Joseph SlimBlock (£89.25) for a small kitchen. Over £120: the Wüsthof Classic or Global G-2 for one premium knife, or the Ninja StaySharp set for someone who will never sharpen by hand.

Related guides

FAQs

Is one chef’s knife better than a knife block set?
For most home cooks, yes. A good 20cm chef’s knife does most jobs, and adding a bread knife and a paring knife covers nearly everything else. A block set is worth it if you are starting from scratch or want a built-in sharpener, but count how many of the pieces you would really use.

Should I buy a German or Japanese-style kitchen knife?
German-style knives such as Wüsthof have a curved, heavier blade for a rocking chop. Japanese-style knives such as the Global G-2 or a santoku are lighter and flatter, with a narrower edge for push-cutting. Choose by how you chop and how the handle feels in your hand.

Can kitchen knives go in the dishwasher?
Some listings say yes, but the knife care advice in the Guardian’s test says never, because the water blunts the blade and the heat weakens the handle. Wash by hand, dry straight away and store on a magnetic strip, in a block or in a drawer guard.

What is a good chef’s knife to give as a gift under £50?
The Victorinox Fibrox 20cm was £38.99 when we checked, and the Guardian named it best budget knife in its March 2026 test. The Victorinox Swiss Classic santoku at £47.00 suits someone who prefers a Japanese-style shape.

Can I buy kitchen knives for a teenager?
GOV.UK says it is illegal to sell most knives to anyone under 18. In Scotland, shops are allowed to sell cutlery and kitchen knives to 16 and 17 year olds. Buy knives as gifts for adults.

Final Thoughts 💡

If you only buy one thing, make it a 20cm chef’s knife. The Victorinox Fibrox at £38.99 is the cheapest good one here, the Robert Welch Signature at £68.00 is the step up, and the Wüsthof Classic at £126.15 was the Guardian’s best overall. Fans of lighter, flatter blades should look at the Global G-2 or try the Victorinox santoku first. If you do want a block, the Ninja StaySharp sharpens itself, the Joseph Joseph SlimBlock fits a tight worktop and the Amazon Basics set covers a first flat for under £17. Watch prices into Black Friday, wash everything by hand and keep the knives somewhere children can’t reach.

For more buying guides and live deals, head to Hotuk.deals.

Disclosure: Hotuk.deals is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising programme designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.co.uk. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability were correct when checked and can change at any time.

Tagged:

One Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.